Home

Is CrossFit Enough?

By Liz

When I was training for my first Ironman triathlon, I was training anywhere between 11 and 17 hours a week. At peak, I was pushing a regular 15-17 hour schedule.

That is a lot of working out.

I am not going to lie to you: I looked absolutely fantastic. As I got closer to the race, I couldn’t KEEP weight on; there was one lovely day when I actually pulled on a pair of jeans while they were still buttoned.

The thing is: that lifestyle is unsustainable. I knew it then, while living it, and I know it even more now, when looking back at it: for me, I cannot sustain 17 hours a week of training, not if I want to remain married and employed and awake. But, you know, that’s kind of the deal you make with Ironman training and it’s fine for that particular goal, just not for life in general. (Note: There are better ways to train for an Ironman; my last one I used Crossfit Endurance, which I’ll write up here next)

So. What to do after Ironman? Well,  as I mentioned before, that’s when I took up Crossfit. I needed something so vastly different from triathlon training (can we say burnout?) and Crossfit was it. I figured that of course I’d gain weight after the race, but hopefully with regular exercise I’d maintain some sort of decent enough body type.

Imagine my surprise when three days a week of Crossfit – averaging generously 3 hours a week-  kept me at the same jean size as my 17 hours a week of IM training. Now, my body type was different, of course – with those three days a week of CF I found myself with more defined muscles overall but without, say, the ability to ride my bike for 5 hours. Given that my goal had shifted from “complete long endurance race” to  “maintain some sort of in shape-ness while not up-ending my entire life in the process” this was a fair trade off for me.

The average Crossfit WOD takes about 20 minutes, with many WODs taking far less. That WOD, coupled with a thorough warm up, plus strength work, plus cool down, is about a 45-60 minute workout overall. The warm-up and strength training portion of the workout are as important as the WOD; if that were skipped I don’t think one would see the same benefits from Crossfit as others (Incidentally, this is why I prefer to do CF at a gym and not on my own; I don’t quite have the discipline to not cut corners).

When people look at Crossfit for the first time, and see the prices, it can be shocking. So much money for so little workout? Why pay THAT MUCH when you’ll have to supplement with additional training? I get it, I do. But I will tell you: with Crossfit as my go-to, main workout focus, I have stayed in shape with far less time investment that with previous undertakings.

I still run. I still swim. I still bike. But I do these things for fun, as they fit into my schedule, not as my main method of staying in shape. And here’s the kicker: I can still run, swim and bike with the same speeds (if not faster, in some cases) than I did when I was ONLY running, swimming, biking.

So, is Crossfit enough? For my current goals, for right now: I certainly think so. I now try to Crossfit 4x/week, and I focus on primal/paleo eating as much as I can, and have found myself able to stay in great shape without the need for excessive time investment. It works for me – has it worked for anyone else?

5 Responses to “Is CrossFit Enough?”

  1. AndreAnna Says:

    Well, you know I drink the Kool-Aid.

    Most average people don’t have more than 4-5 hours a week to give to exercise without sacrificing something else, and all too often I think people get hung up on that.

    That they have to spend 90 minutes a day on the rteadmill and 45 minutes a day with weights, EIGHT DAYS A WEEK. And then to do that they have to give up something else? Maybe leisure reading? Maybe a night out with a friend?

    Crap, I say.

    I am fitter from the 4 days a week of XF than I have been in my entire life. And that’s including when I thought I was in shape at 21.

  2. AndreAnna Says:

    Gah, I wasn’t done!! Stupid tab key. Ahem.

    My point was that people often give up on fitness or being fit because they think its an unattainable goal they have to sacrifice for.

    And it isn’t.

    And to me, worth every damn penny of the exrta 12 hours a week I have.

  3. Liz Says:

    AndreAnna – yes exactly – the intensity investment of CrossFit is equal to the time investment of others, for me, and in my opinion, etc etc.

    It’s worth noting – and I should have way made these two points more hugely:
    1. The best working out is the working out you will actually DO, so if you have something that is fun for you, do that
    2. Everything is goal dependent. If your goal is to run a marathon then focusing solely on CF might not be the best option. Since my goal is currently to stay in shape, this is what works for me.

  4. Kate G. Says:

    Wow. This is encouraging. I’m assuming it’s related to changing your body compisition a bit with CrossFit so that you’re a muscle-burning machine?
    Pure aerobic work has only gotten me so far with losing weight. As we age women especially seem to need to add in weight-bearing work.
    I’m becomming more an more curious about CrossFit…

  5. Rosina Brittian Says:

    Quite a beautiful website. I built mine and i was looking for some design ideas and you gave me a few. Did you develop the website alone?

    Cheers

Leave a Reply

Blogs